Destructive Pholiota

(Hemipholiota populnea)

Conservation Status

Destructive Pholiota
Photo by Margot Avey
IUCN Red List

not listed

 
NatureServe

NNR - Unranked

 
Minnesota

not listed

 
     
     
     
     

Description

Destructive Pholiota is a large, late season, wood-rotting mushroom. It occurs in Europe, western Asia, and North America. In the United States it occurs from Vermont to Pennsylvania, west to Washington, northern California, and New Mexico. It is mostly absent from the south, the Great Plains, and the desert southwest. It is found in late summer and fall; alone, in groups, or in clusters; in floodplains and riparian areas. It grows on dead wood of poplar, especially cottonwood and balsam poplar, and occasionally also in willows. It is often seen on recently cut surfaces of logs. It obtains its nutrients from dead wood (saprobic). It rapidly decomposes wood, and this is the feature that gives it one of its common names.

When it first appears, the cap is convex and usually white to creamy buff, sometimes yellowish-brown or orangish-brown. The upper surface is hairless and dry but sticky when moist. It is conspicuously covered with whitish to buff, cottony scales or patches, remnants of the partial veil. More shaggy remnants cling to the margins. As it ages the cap flattens out, becoming broadly convex, and the scales become matted down or wash off. Mature caps can be 2¼ to 8 (6 to 20 cm) in diameter but are usually no more than 6¼ (16 cm) in diameter.

The stalk is robust, solid, hard, white, and abundantly covered with scales. It can be 1½ to 7 (4 to 18 cm) long but is usually no more than 4 (10 cm) in length. It is to 1¼ (1 to 3 cm) thick at the top, equal or sometimes expanding to 2 to 2¾ (5 to 7 cm) thick at the base. It may be attached in the center of the cap or off-center. As it ages it turns brownish, at least near the base. Part of the partial veil remains as a small ring near the top of the stalk. The ring is covered with cottony, hair-like fibers (fibrillose). It curves downward and becomes completely covered with cinnamon brown spores.

The gills are closely spaced. They may be notched at the stalk or broadly attached (adnate). They are white at first, becoming brown to cinnamon-brown at maturity. There are frequent secondary, short gills between the main gills.

The flesh is thick, firm, and white. It does not change color when sliced. It is edible but tough and the taste is disagreeable.

The spore print is cinnamon brown.

Similar Species

 

Habitat and Hosts

Floodplains and riparian areas

Cottonwood and balsam poplar, and occasionally willow

Ecology

Season

Late summer and fall

Distribution

Distribution Map

 

Sources

24, 26, 29, 30, 77.

Biodiversity occurrence data published by: Minnesota Biodiversity Atlas (accessed through the Minnesota Biodiversity Atlas Portal, bellatlas.umn.edu, 11/8/2025).

11/8/2025    
     

Occurrence

 

Taxonomy

Kingdom

Fungi (fungi)

Subkingdom

Dikarya

Phylum

Basidiomycota (club fungi)

Subphylum

Agaricomycotina (jelly fungi, yeasts, and mushrooms)

Class

Agaricomycetes (mushrooms, bracket fungi, puffballs, and allies)

Subclass

Agaricomycetidae

Order

Agaricales (common gilled mushrooms and allies)

Suborder

Agaricineae

Family

Hymenogastraceae

Genus

Hemipholiota

 

Genus
This mushroom was formerly classified as Pholiota destruens and was the type species in the subgenus Hemipholiota. A study published in 1986 showed that the correct name of the species should be Pholiota populnea. The subgenus Hemipholiota was broadly defined and contained 15 species that were not similar in appearance. Several studies showed the grouping to be unnatural, and by 2003 the subgenus contained only 3 species, including Pholiota populnea. DNA studies published in 2002 and 2007 showed that the subgenus was clearly not closely related to the type species of Pholiota, and Hemipholiota was raised to genus level. This phylogenetic separation also necessitated a reconsideration of its family placement.

Family
The family placement of Hemipholiota populnea (formerly Pholiota populnea) is currently debated, reflecting the transition from traditional to molecular classification. It was long placed in the family Strophariaceae based on morphological similarities like its rusty-brown spores and wood-rotting habit. However, extensive DNA sequencing (phylogenetics) has definitively shown that the Hemipholiota lineage is not closely related to the core Pholiota genus, and modern classifications indicate it should be placed in the family Hymenogastraceae.

Subordinate Taxa

 

Synonyms

Agaricus comosus

Agaricus comosus var. albus

Agaricus destruens

Agaricus populneus

Dryophila destruens

Hemipholiota comosa

Hemipholiota destruens

Myxocybe destruens

Pholiota comosa

Pholiota comosa

Pholiota comosa var. alba

Pholiota destruens

Pholiota destruens var. edmundii

Pholiota populnea

Common Names

Destructive Pholiota

Poplar Pholiota

 

 

 

 

 

 

Glossary

Partial veil

A protective covering over the gills or pores of a developing mushroom. At maturity it disappears, collapses into a ring around the stalk, or wears away into a cobwebby covering and ring zone.

 

Saprobic

A term often used for saprotrophic fungi. Referring to fungi that obtain their nutrients from decayed organic matter.

 

Visitor Photos

Share your photo of this fungus.

This button not working for you?
Simply email us at info@MinnesotaSeasons.com.
Attach one or more photos and, if you like, a caption.

Dan W. Andree

Destructive Pholiota

This one is kind of homely...

Probably because it’s decaying. Was growing out of a downed tree trunk in some woodlands over by Twin Valley, Mn. Sept. 11, 2025

Margot Avey

Destructive Pholiota   Destructive Pholiota
     
Destructive Pholiota   Destructive Pholiota
     
Destructive Pholiota    
Interesting place to grow!  

 

MinnesotaSeasons.com Photos

     
   

 

 

Camera

Slideshows

 
 

 

Xxxxxxxxxxxx

 

slideshow

Visitor Videos

Share your video of this fungus.

This button not working for you?
Simply email us at info@MinnesotaSeasons.com.
Attach a video, a YouTube link, or a cloud storage link.

 

 
 

 

Xxxxxxxxxxxx

Xxxxxxxxxxxx

Other Videos

Pholiota populnea
Apostle of Azathoth

About

Sep 24, 2021

 

Camcorder

Visitor Sightings

Report a sighting of this fungus.

This button not working for you?
Simply email us at info@MinnesotaSeasons.com.
Be sure to include a location.

Dan W. Andree
9/11/2025

Destructive Pholiota

Location: Norman Co. Mn.

This one is kind of homely... Probably because it’s decaying. Was growing out of a downed tree trunk in some woodlands over by Twin Valley, Mn. Sept. 11, 2025

Margot Avey
9/17/2022

Destructive Pholiota

Location: Westwood Hills Nature Center, St. Louis Park, MN

Interesting place to grow!

Margot Avey
9/6/2022

Destructive Pholiota

Location: Westwood Hills Nature Center, St. Louis Park, MN

Margot Avey
9/2/2022

Destructive Pholiota

Location: Westwood Hills Nature Center, St. Louis Park, MN

MinnesotaSeasons.com Sightings

 

 

 

Binoculars